Back to Top

NSA's 2018 Puzzle Periodical

Try your hand at this month's problem written by a member of our expert workforce.

January 2018 Puzzle Periodical - Snow Manipulation

Can Frosty the Snowman build a new spherical snowman?

Puzzle created by James M., NSA Operations Researcher

Frosty's Idea

Frosty the Snowman wants to create a small snowman friend for himself. The new snowman needs a base, torso, and a head, all three of which should be spheres. The torso should be no larger than the base and the head should be no larger than the torso.

For building material, Frosty has a spherical snowball with a 6 inch radius. Since Frosty likes to keep things simple, he also wants the radius of each of the three pieces to be a positive integer. Can Frosty accomplish this?

Click to see the answer!

Did you solve the scenario - Can Frosty the Snowman build a new spherical snowman?

Illustration of a large sphere on the left side of an equal sign and 3 stacked spheres that increase in size to form the shape of a snowman on the right side of the equal sign. The largest sphere at the base of the stack is smaller than the single large sphere to the left.Can you calculate the spherical snowball radii for the new snowman? The original snowball has a 6 inch radius (shown on the far left).
Yes! The formula for the volume of a sphere with radius r is 43 π r3. Let a, b and c be the radii of the base, torso, and head, respectively, which are integers greater than 0. The problem then amounts to Frosty solving the equation

43 π 63 = 43 π a3 + 43 π b3 + 43 π c3
= 43 π (a3 + b3 + c3)

By canceling out the factor of 43 π from both sides, we're left with

216 = a3 + b3 + c3

As stated in the problem, a ≥ b ≥ c. The biggest that a can be is 5, so let's try that first. Subtracting 53 = 125 from both sides gives us

91 = b3+c3

The biggest that b can be is 4, so let's try that next. Subtracting 43 = 64 from both sides gives us

27 =c3

Frosty is in luck, since 33 = 27. Thus we have that 63 = 53 + 43 + 33. Now Frosty can build his new snowman friend to his specifications. In fact, (5, 4, 3) is the only combination of numbers that will work.

Snow Manipulation Solution:

Same as prior illustration, but with radii identified.
The original snowball has a 6 inch radius. Radii of the new spheres are: 3, 4, and 5.