# NSA's 2016 Puzzle Periodical

Try your hand at this month's problem written by a member of our expert workforce.

Skip Site Navigation

- NSA.gov
- About Us
- Mission & Strategy
- Leadership
- Central Security Service (CSS)
- Cryptologic Centers
- EEO & Diversity
- Civil Liberties
- Cryptologic Heritage
- NSA Advisory Board (NSAAB)
- Office of the Inspector General
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Contact NSA

- What We Do
- News & Features
- Resources For …
- Careers & Programs
- Doing Business With Us

December 20, 2016

*Submitted by James M., NSA, Operations Researcher*

RATS x 4 = STAR

Each instance of a letter stands for the same digit, no two letters represent the same digit, and R cannot be 0. Which digits do the four letters represent?

RATS x 4 = STAR

Since the product is four digits long, RATS can be no greater than 9999/4. Thus the largest RATS can be 2499. This tells us that R is either 1 or 2.

Can R be 1? We also know that S x 4 ends in R. Since 4 is even and an even number times anything results in an even number, R must be even. Thus R can’t be 1, so must be 2.

2ATS x 4 = STA2

Since R = 2, we know 2ATS is somewhere between 2000 and 2499. Thus the product is somewhere between 8000 and 9996, and S must be 8 or 9.

Can S be 9? We know that S x 4 results in a number that ends in 2. 9 x 4 = 36, which ends in 6. 8 x 4 = 32, which does end in 2. Thus S = 8.

2AT8 x 4 = 8TA2

When we multiply 8 by 4, we get 32. We write down the 2 and carry the 3. Thus we know that T x 4 + 3 ends in A. Since T x 4 is even, T x 4 + 3 must be odd, so A is odd. Since the product is between 8002 and 8992, 2AT8 must be between 2001 and 2248. So A is between 0 and 2. The only odd number in that range is 1, so A = 1.

21T8 x 4 = 8T12

For T x 4 + 3 to end in 1, T x 4 must end in 8. The only values that will work are 2 and 7. R is already 2, so T can’t be 2. Thus T must be 7. Checking our work, we indeed get that

2178 x 4 = 8712

So we see that 2178 times 4 equals its reverse. Furthermore, 2178 x 2 = 4356 and 2178 x 3 = 6534, and those values are the reverse of each other as well.